dark

Sola Scriptura’s Self Refutation

Signup for our Newsletter today for Catholic content

The Protestant error of “sola scriptura” is self refuting. The term “sola scriptura” can be defined as follows: “The Bible and only the Bible is the infallible rule of faith.” But the words “only the Bible” can be translated into Latin as “sola scriptura”.

Substituting this into the above definition we have: “The Bible and ‘sola scriptura’ is the rule of faith.”

This shows that “sola scriptura” logically refutes itself because this principle must be assumed to be true IN ADDITION TO the Bible. As such, “sola scriptura” refutes what it purports to claim.

This is an application of Kurt Godel’s Secod Incompleteness Theorem from metamathematical analysis. Self-referential statements (such as the Liar Paradox of Epimenides or using the Bible to prove the Bible to be the sole rule of faith independant of any external referent) are notorious for making statements which are logically unprovable within the formal system that makes the claim. It is only by assuming a transcendental position outside the system under scrutiny that such contentions can be proven true or false.

In the case of “sola scriptura,” the necessity of assuming the transcendental position in and of itself refutes the principle under question.

By Art Sippo

Support Our Mission of Evangelization

Patreon
Become a Patron!
Buy Me a Coffee




PayPal
Select a Donation Option (USD)

Enter Donation Amount (USD)

Oldest And Most Powerful Prayer To St. Joseph Never Known To Fail

Total
32
Shares
Subscribe
Notify of
guest
0 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Related Posts