Why Catholics Cannot Be Masons Book Summary

Listen to this article

Title: Why Catholics Cannot Be Masons
Author: John Salza

TLDR: A former high-ranking Freemason who returned back to his Catholic faith exposes the theological errors of Freemasonry and explains why its teachings are fundamentally incompatible with Catholic doctrine.

Chapter 1: A Harmless Fraternal Organization?

This chapter sets the stage by addressing the common perception of Freemasonry as a harmless fraternal organization dedicated to bettering its members and society. John Salza argues that this perception is carefully cultivated by Freemasons themselves, who are sworn to secrecy about their true teachings. The general public remains unaware of the doctrines and rituals practiced within the confines of Masonic lodges.

Salza emphasizes the numerous papal condemnations of Freemasonry issued over centuries, demonstrating the Catholic Church’s longstanding and unwavering opposition to the organization. He dismisses the claims of some “Catholic” Masons that these condemnations are irrelevant to American Freemasonry or politically motivated. He argues that the Church’s position applies universally, regardless of geographical location or variations in Masonic rituals.

The heart of the issue, Salza argues, lies in the irreconcilable differences between Masonic teachings and Catholic doctrine. He highlights the dogma of “No Salvation Outside the Church,” a cornerstone of Catholic belief that stands in direct opposition to Freemasonry’s acceptance of all religions as valid paths to God.

Salza concludes the chapter by emphasizing the gravity of disregarding papal pronouncements, which Catholics believe to be protected from error by the Holy Spirit. He underscores that recognizing and submitting to the Pope’s authority is essential for salvation.

Chapter 2: The History and Purpose of Freemasonry

This chapter delves into the history and structure of Freemasonry, tracing its roots back to the medieval stonemasons’ guilds. It charts the transition from “operative” masonry, focused on physical construction, to “speculative” masonry, concerned with building a “spiritual temple” within each member.

Salza highlights the significance of 1717, marked by the establishment of the Grand Lodge of England and considered the birth of modern Freemasonry. He outlines the hierarchical structure of the organization, from the foundational Blue Lodge, where members receive the first three degrees, to the optional Scottish and York Rites, culminating in the Shriners.

The chapter emphasizes that while individual Grand Lodges operate independently, they all adhere to the fundamental tenets or “Landmarks” of Freemasonry, ensuring consistency in their teachings and practices. These Landmarks include a belief in God as the “Grand Architect of the Universe,” the importance of oaths and secrecy, and the concepts of immortality and resurrection.

The chapter concludes by reiterating that the ultimate goal of Freemasonry is to guide its members towards Heaven through its unique system of morality and symbolism, purportedly leading them to “the Lodge in heaven.”

Chapter 3: An Introduction to the Errors of Freemasonry

This chapter delves into the core theological discrepancies between Freemasonry and Catholicism. Salza argues that Freemasonry denies the unique role of Jesus Christ and His Church in achieving salvation. By accepting all religions as equally valid paths to God, Freemasonry promotes the heresy of Indifferentism, which the Catholic Church has consistently condemned.

Salza traces the influence of Enlightenment thinking on Freemasonry, highlighting the organization’s emphasis on reason and naturalism over divine revelation and the authority of the Church. He argues that Freemasonry’s reliance on “rational homage to Deity” and the study of “geometry” as gateways to God diminishes the importance of faith and the supernatural truths revealed by Christ.

The chapter further criticizes Freemasonry’s syncretistic approach, which blends elements of various religions into a single system, blurring the lines between truth and error. Salza argues that this syncretism extends even to the concept of God, with Freemasonry embracing a generic “deity” that can accommodate a wide range of beliefs, including polytheism.

Salza concludes by emphasizing the danger of Freemasonry’s deceptive use of Christian-sounding terminology and symbolism, which can mislead Catholics into believing that the two systems are compatible. He warns that this deceptive tactic is reminiscent of Modernism, a condemned heresy that sought to reconcile Catholic teachings with modern ideas, ultimately undermining the integrity of the Faith.

Chapter 4: Preparation for the First Degree

This chapter marks the beginning of Salza’s detailed exposition of the Masonic initiation process, focusing on the first degree of Entered Apprentice. He describes the ritualistic stripping of the candidate’s clothing and removal of any religious symbols, including wedding rings, crucifixes, and scapulars.

Salza argues that this divestment symbolizes a rejection of the candidate’s pre-existing faith and a commitment to the new “truths” of Freemasonry. This requirement, he asserts, contradicts Freemasonry’s claim of respecting its members’ individual faiths, highlighting its underlying intention to supplant those faiths with its own system of belief.

The chapter ends with the candidate, blindfolded with a “hoodwink” and bound with a “cabletow,” standing at the Inner Door of the Lodge, ready to be “brought to light” from his perceived state of spiritual darkness.

Chapter 5: Spiritual Darkness

This chapter analyzes the symbolism of the Entered Apprentice initiation, particularly the concept of the candidate being “brought to light.” Salza criticizes Freemasonry’s assertion that the candidate has “long been in darkness,” despite his potential baptism into the light of Christ. He argues that this statement demonstrates Freemasonry’s disregard for the grace and enlightenment bestowed by Christian baptism, positioning itself as the true source of spiritual illumination.

Salza exposes the deceptive nature of Freemasonry’s “light,” contrasting it with the true light of Christ that illuminates the hearts and minds of believers. He further argues that Freemasonry’s claim to elevate its members to “sons of light” diminishes the significance of being reborn as children of God through baptism.

The chapter concludes with the candidate facing a stark choice between the light of Christ and the darkness disguised as light offered by Freemasonry.

Chapter 6: Freemasonry’s Worship of “Deity”

This chapter delves into Freemasonry’s ambiguous concept of God. Salza criticizes the organization’s use of generic terms like “Grand Architect of the Universe” and its deliberate omission of Jesus Christ’s name from prayers. He argues that this practice, while seemingly inclusive, undermines the unique role of Jesus as the Son of God and the sole mediator between God and man.

Salza compares Freemasonry’s approach to the pagan worship encountered by St. Paul in Athens. He argues that just as St. Paul condemned idolatry and called for conversion to Christ, so too must Catholics reject the worship of a generic “deity” that disregards the truth of the Holy Trinity.

The chapter emphasizes the Church’s historical prohibition against Catholics worshipping with non-Catholics, a prohibition that extends to Freemasons. Salza argues that joint prayer with Masons not only violates this rule but also obscures the truths of salvation and the unity of the Church. He warns that such practices can lead Catholics astray from their faith.

Chapter 7: Who Is the God of Freemasonry?

This chapter further scrutinizes Freemasonry’s concept of God, focusing on its symbolic representations. Salza discusses the letter “G,” representing both “God” and “Geometry,” and the “All-Seeing Eye,” both commonly displayed in Masonic lodges. He argues that these symbols, devoid of specific religious connotations, facilitate Freemasonry’s syncretistic approach to religion, blending various faiths into a single system that ultimately denies the unique truth of Christianity.

Salza argues that Freemasonry’s acceptance of diverse interpretations of God extends beyond monotheism, even encompassing polytheistic beliefs. He criticizes the organization’s rejection of any “specific kind of Supreme Deity,” which effectively equates the true God with false gods.

The chapter concludes by emphasizing that Freemasonry’s “Grand Architect of the Universe” is not the Holy Trinity of Christian belief, making it a false god. Salza reiterates the First Commandment’s prohibition against idolatry and warns Catholics against participating in any form of worship that disregards the one true God.

Chapter 8: Freemasonry’s Profession of Faith in the Deity

This chapter examines the Masonic initiation oath and its implications. Salza criticizes the lodge’s acceptance of any “supreme deity” professed by the candidate, regardless of its compatibility with Christian belief. He argues that this indiscriminate acceptance effectively endorses falsehood as readily as truth, demonstrating a disregard for objective truth itself.

Salza contrasts this relativistic approach with the Catholic Church’s unwavering commitment to the truths revealed by Jesus Christ. He quotes papal pronouncements condemning Indifferentism and emphasizes that contradictory beliefs about God cannot be simultaneously true. He argues that embracing such contradictions violates both reason and faith.

The chapter concludes by reiterating the importance of remaining separate from those who reject the true God, echoing St. Paul’s warning against yoking oneself to unbelievers. Salza emphasizes that fellowship with those who espouse falsehood can endanger one’s own salvation.

Chapter 9: Freemasonry’s Oaths

This chapter focuses on the oaths sworn by Masonic initiates, arguing that these oaths violate the Second Commandment’s prohibition against taking God’s name in vain. Salza criticizes the use of bloodcurdling self-curses within the oaths, highlighting their blasphemous nature and incompatibility with Christian morality. He argues that swearing such oaths constitutes a grave sin and jeopardizes the soul’s salvation.

Salza further differentiates Masonic oaths from pledges taken by Catholic fraternal organizations like the Knights of Columbus. He points out that Masonic oaths invoke God’s name directly as witness to the promises made, while Catholic pledges rely on the individual’s word of honor. He also emphasizes the secretive nature of Masonic oaths, which are not revealed to the candidate beforehand, contrasting them with the transparency of Catholic pledges.

The chapter concludes by condemning Freemasonry’s requirement of physically enacting the self-curses through hand gestures, further reinforcing their blasphemous and sacrilegious nature. Salza emphasizes that the Masonic oaths, unlike Catholic pledges, ultimately serve to distance individuals from Christ rather than draw them closer to Him.

Chapter 10: Freemasonry’s View Of the Holy Bible

This chapter delves into Freemasonry’s treatment of the Bible. Salza explains that while the Bible is present during Masonic rituals, it is regarded merely as a symbol of God’s will, equal in standing to other religious texts. He criticizes this view, which diminishes the Bible’s status as the inspired Word of God and undermines its unique authority for Christians.

Salza argues that Freemasonry’s willingness to replace the Bible with other religious writings reflects its relativistic approach to truth. He emphasizes the Catholic Church’s teaching on the Bible’s divine inspiration and inerrancy, contrasting it with Freemasonry’s view of Scripture as a replaceable symbol.

The chapter concludes by denouncing the logic behind Freemasonry’s acceptance of contradictory religious texts as equally valid expressions of God’s will. Salza argues that this approach is not only illogical but also dangerous, as it blurs the lines between truth and falsehood, potentially leading individuals astray from the true God.

Chapter 11: Freemasonry’s Salvation By Works

This chapter tackles Freemasonry’s doctrine of salvation, arguing that it contradicts the Catholic Church’s teaching on grace and justification. Salza examines Masonic symbols like the lambskin apron and the working tools, interpreting them as promoting a works-based path to salvation. He argues that this emphasis on “purity of life and conduct” ignores the essential role of God’s grace, received through Jesus Christ, in achieving salvation.

Salza emphasizes the Catholic Church’s teaching that salvation is impossible through human effort alone. He reiterates the Council of Trent’s condemnation of the heresy that man can be justified before God by his own works without divine grace. He argues that Freemasonry’s moralistic approach reduces the Catholic faith to a mere ethical system, ignoring its supernatural dimensions and the essential role of Christ’s sacrifice.

The chapter concludes by reminding Catholics that true salvation comes through faith in Jesus Christ and through adherence to the teachings of His Church. Salza emphasizes that good works, while important, are only meritorious when performed in a state of grace, a state that Freemasonry disregards.

Chapter 12: Freemasonry’s Doctrine of Resurrection of the Body

This chapter examines the Masonic teaching on resurrection, presented through the allegorical Hiramic Legend during the Master Mason initiation. Salza criticizes the legend’s portrayal of resurrection as a symbolic event achieved through good works and Masonic principles, rather than through the power of Jesus Christ’s own resurrection.

He highlights the Catholic Church’s teaching that the resurrection of the body is a future reality for all believers, made possible by Christ’s victory over death. He argues that Freemasonry’s omission of Christ from its resurrection doctrine renders it heretical, as it denies the unique role of Christ as “the resurrection and the life.”

Salza concludes by emphasizing that Catholics cannot accept “revelations” or teachings that contradict the truth revealed by Jesus Christ. He warns that embracing Freemasonry’s heretical doctrine on resurrection jeopardizes one’s salvation.

Chapter 13: The Clear, Consistent Teaching of the Church

This chapter reiterates the Catholic Church’s unwavering stance on Freemasonry. Salza emphasizes that the Church’s numerous condemnations of Freemasonry are infallible pronouncements, binding on all Catholics. He argues that Catholics who choose to join or remain in the Masonic Lodge risk separating themselves from Christ and His Church, thereby endangering their salvation.

Salza addresses the changes made to the Code of Canon Law in 1983 regarding Freemasonry. He clarifies that while the new Code no longer explicitly names Freemasonry, it broadens the scope of censure to include any organization that plots against the Church. He emphasizes that the Church’s position on Freemasonry remains unchanged, with Catholics who join Masonic lodges still considered to be in a state of grave sin.

The chapter further discusses the 1983 “Declaration on Masonic Associations,” reaffirming the Church’s stance that Masonic principles are incompatible with Catholic doctrine. This declaration emphasizes that membership in Masonic associations remains forbidden for Catholics, and those who choose to join are barred from receiving Holy Communion.

Salza concludes by emphasizing the gravity of receiving Holy Communion while in a state of mortal sin, a sin that includes knowingly and obstinately adhering to Masonic teachings. He urges “Catholic” Masons to renounce their Masonic membership and seek reconciliation with the Church through the Sacrament of Penance.

Chapter 14: Conclusion

The final chapter summarizes the key arguments against Freemasonry, reiterating that the organization’s teachings contradict Catholic doctrine on fundamental issues like the nature of God, the path to salvation, and the role of Jesus Christ. Salza emphasizes that Freemasonry’s seemingly benevolent facade masks a dangerous and deceptive system of belief that can lead individuals astray from the one true God.

He reiterates the Catholic Church’s loving concern for the salvation of souls, explaining that its opposition to Freemasonry stems from a desire to protect its members from spiritual harm. He urges Catholics to educate themselves about the dangers of Freemasonry and to resist its allure.

Salza concludes with a call to action, urging Catholics to boldly confront the errors of Freemasonry and to pray for the conversion of those who have been deceived by its teachings. He emphasizes that the stakes are eternal, and that choosing Christ over Freemasonry is essential for securing one’s salvation.

The book ends with a call to embrace the truth and love of Jesus Christ, rejecting the false promises of Freemasonry. Salza’s personal journey serves as a powerful reminder of the transformative power of faith and the importance of remaining vigilant against ideologies that seek to undermine the one true Church established by Christ.

🙏 Your PayPal Donation Appreciated

Select a Donation Option (USD)

Enter Donation Amount (USD)


As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases. Thank you.

Note: While content aims to align with Catholic teachings, any inconsistencies or errors are unintended. For precise understanding, always refer to authoritative sources like the Catechism of the Catholic Church. Always double-check any quotes for word-for-word accuracy with the Bible or the Catechism of the Catholic Church.

Scroll to Top