Brief Overview
- Throughout history, certain saints saw that the Catholic faith was being lived in ways that did not match what the Church actually taught, and they worked to bring change.
- These holy men and women often faced criticism and even punishment from both church leaders and ordinary people who did not want the faith reformed.
- Saint Francis of Assisi rejected the wealth and power that the Church had gained and lived in poverty to follow Jesus more closely.
- Saint Catherine of Siena convinced the Pope to return to Rome and also challenged bishops and priests to live better lives.
- Saint Ignatius of Loyola created new ways to teach and serve that helped the Church respond to the problems of his time.
- These saints show us that true faithfulness to God sometimes means speaking against what everyone else is doing and accepting the cost of that choice.
The Problem of Wealth in the Medieval Church
The Catholic Church in the Middle Ages grew very rich and very powerful. Bishops and priests owned large amounts of land and property. They controlled armies and made political decisions that affected kingdoms. Many Catholics saw the clergy living like kings instead of like the followers of Jesus who had nothing. The common people watched priests wear fancy clothes and live in grand buildings while ordinary folk struggled to survive. This gap between what Jesus taught and what Church leaders did troubled many faithful Catholics. Some people began to question whether the Church was really following Christ at all. Others felt angry that their money, given as donations to the Church, went to pay for luxuries. The need for reform grew stronger as time passed and nothing seemed to change. Saints who lived during this time had to decide whether to accept this situation or to challenge it.
Saint Francis and His Vision of Holy Poverty
Francis of Assisi lived in Italy during the late 1100s and early 1200s. He came from a wealthy family and had every comfort available to a young man of his class. One day, Francis experienced a vision that changed his entire life. He felt called by Jesus to leave his family’s money behind and to live as the poorest of the poor. Francis stripped off his fine clothes and walked away from his father’s house with nothing but rags. He chose to sleep outside, to beg for food, and to own nothing at all. His own father was furious and disowned him in front of the entire town. Many people thought Francis had gone mad to reject wealth so completely. The Church leaders in Rome were suspicious of this strange new way of living. Yet Francis said he was simply trying to follow the example that Jesus had shown. He wanted to return the Church to the simplicity and freedom that came from owning nothing. His radical choice started a movement that eventually became the Franciscan order.
Francis Gathers Followers and Faces Opposition
As Francis lived his poor and simple life, other people began to notice him. Some young men felt inspired by his example and wanted to join him in this new way. They started to form a community of brothers who all chose poverty and simplicity. The group grew quickly, and soon Francis had hundreds of followers living throughout Italy. These Franciscans went out into towns and villages to teach people about Christ. They worked with the sick and cared for lepers when other people turned away from them. They preached that the Church should sell its property and give the money to the poor. Church officials began to see this as a threat to their authority and power. Some bishops tried to stop Francis from speaking or gathering crowds. Others accused him of being proud and disobedient to the Church hierarchy. The Pope himself had to decide whether to approve or reject this strange new religious community. Eventually, Pope Innocent III recognized the Franciscan order, but with strict limits on what they could do.
The Message That Francis Brought to the Church
Francis did not reject the Church itself or the Pope’s authority in Rome. Instead, he said that the Church had lost sight of what it should really be about. He pointed out that Jesus had taught his followers to give up everything and to trust God for their needs. Francis showed through his own life that this teaching was still possible in his own time. He lived in complete trust that God would provide what he needed each day. He treated the poor and sick with honor and respect because he saw Jesus in them. He preached that wealth and power actually made it harder to follow Christ properly. His message made wealthy bishops and cardinals uncomfortable because it criticized their way of life. At the same time, his message gave hope to ordinary people who felt left out of the Church. Francis proved that someone could be deeply Catholic and deeply opposed to how the Church was organized. His life showed that faithfulness to Christ and faithfulness to the Church did not have to mean accepting everything the Church did. This distinction helped many people see that reform from within was both possible and necessary.
Saint Catherine of Siena and Her Bold Letters
Catherine of Siena lived in Italy during the 1300s, nearly two hundred years after Francis died. She was a woman from a working-class family who never received formal education like the wealthy did. Despite having no training in theology or church law, Catherine became known for her wisdom and her strong faith. She began to write letters to important Church leaders, including the Pope himself. These letters spoke directly about the problems she saw in the Church. She told bishops that they were not doing their jobs properly and that God would judge them for their failures. She wrote to the Pope that he needed to show leadership and make hard decisions for reform. She challenged cardinals and priests to live according to their vows instead of chasing money and power. Her letters were bold and direct in ways that would normally be considered disrespectful. Yet people listened to her because they could see that she spoke from genuine love for the Church. Catherine did not write these letters out of anger or desire for attention. She wrote them because she believed that the Church was being harmed by corruption and that someone had to speak the truth.
Catherine’s Work to Reform the Papacy
One of Catherine’s most important actions involved the Pope himself. During her time, the Pope lived in Avignon, France, instead of in Rome where the headquarters of the Church was supposed to be. Many Catholics felt that this was wrong and that it showed the Pope had lost his way. Catherine wrote powerful letters to Pope Gregory XI telling him to return to Rome. She told him that God was calling him to lead the Church from its proper home. She said that by staying in Avignon, he was abandoning his responsibility to the Church. Catherine was so persistent and so persuasive that other people began to support her message. Eventually, Pope Gregory XI did return to Rome in the year 1377. This was a huge change, and many people recognized that Catherine’s voice had helped make it happen. When the Pope died shortly after returning to Rome, a new Pope was elected to succeed him. The situation became complex and difficult, but Catherine continued to work for what she believed was right. She never stopped writing letters and never stopped speaking to leaders about their duties before God. Catherine showed that one person, especially someone with no official power or title, could still make a real difference in the Church.
Saint Ignatius of Loyola and New Ways of Teaching
Ignatius of Loyola lived during the 1500s when the Church was facing serious problems. Protestant churches had broken away from Rome, and many Catholics were confused about what the Church really believed. The Church needed new ways to teach and to respond to these challenges. Ignatius was a Spanish soldier who experienced a religious conversion after being badly wounded in battle. During his recovery, he read books about Jesus and the saints, and his entire outlook on life changed. He spent time in prayer and thought carefully about how God was calling him to serve. Ignatius began to develop a system of prayer and thinking that he called “spiritual exercises.” These exercises helped people understand what God wanted from their lives in practical ways. He realized that the Church needed trained teachers who could explain faith clearly to ordinary people. He also saw that the Church needed people who would go anywhere in the world to spread the faith. Ignatius decided to start a religious community called the Society of Jesus, often known as the Jesuits. This order would focus on education, mission work, and careful thinking about how to serve the Church in new ways. His approach was very different from the way religious communities had worked in earlier centuries.
The Jesuit Approach to Education and Service
The Jesuits developed schools and universities throughout Europe and beyond. They trained priests and teachers who could explain the faith in clear, reasonable ways. This was different from how things had been done before, when education was mostly reserved for the wealthy and for those preparing to become clergy. The Jesuits believed that ordinary people deserved to understand their faith deeply. They wrote books and gave talks that used reason and argument to show why Christian beliefs made sense. This approach challenged the idea that faith had to be a matter of blind obedience to whatever the Church said. The Jesuits also sent missionaries to distant lands to teach people about Christ. This was not entirely new, but the Jesuits were more organized and more careful in how they prepared their missionaries. They studied the languages and customs of the people they would serve. They tried to find ways to teach the faith that would make sense within each culture. This practical and thoughtful approach was new for the Church at that time. Ignatius and the Jesuits showed that the Church could change how it did things without changing what it believed. They proved that tradition and new thinking could work together.
Internal Resistance to Ignatius and the Jesuits
Even though the Pope approved the Jesuit order, other parts of the Church were not always happy with what Ignatius was doing. Some older religious communities felt threatened by the success of the Jesuits. They worried that their own importance and influence would decrease. Bishops who had not received much education sometimes felt that the Jesuits were acting superior to them. They complained that Ignatius was trying to change too much too fast. Some priests accused the Jesuits of being too focused on reason and not enough on faith and tradition. They said that the Jesuits were making the faith too complicated by trying to explain everything. Others worried that by going to distant lands and adapting to local cultures, the Jesuits were not really staying true to Catholic teaching. These criticisms came from people who genuinely loved the Church but who disagreed with Ignatius about how change should happen. Ignatius had to defend his approach many times and had to prove that the Jesuits were loyal to the Pope and to Catholic teaching. He also had to be willing to make some changes to his plans when Church leaders said they were going too far. This balance between staying true to his vision and respecting the Church’s authority was difficult and required constant work. Yet Ignatius persisted because he believed that his way of working would actually help the Church serve people better.
Saint Teresa of Calcutta and Challenge to Modern Catholicism
Teresa of Calcutta lived in the twentieth century, which is a much more recent time than the other saints mentioned here. She was born in Europe but spent most of her life working in India with people who were dying in the streets. She founded a community called the Missionaries of Charity that cared for the poorest and most rejected people. In many ways, her work was similar to what Francis of Assisi had done centuries earlier. She insisted on living simply and owning almost nothing, even as the Church became wealthier. She challenged Catholics in wealthy countries to remember that Jesus cared especially for the poor and suffering. She showed that it was possible to do heroic work without needing money or power or recognition. Her actions challenged Catholics who thought that following Christ meant being comfortable and respectable. She also challenged the Church itself to care more directly about suffering people instead of focusing only on buildings and organizations. Some Church leaders and wealthy Catholics did not like her message because it made them feel guilty. They said she was being too radical or too critical of how Catholics lived their lives. Yet Teresa never stopped speaking about the needs of the poorest people. She lived in a way that showed she meant what she said. Many Catholics came to see her as an example of what real faithfulness to Christ looked like.
The Pattern of Saints Speaking Against Their Culture
Looking at these saints together, a clear pattern becomes visible. Each of them saw that the way Catholics were living did not match what the faith actually taught. Each of them was willing to say so, even though this made them unpopular or brought them trouble. Francis challenged wealth and power when those things were deeply valued in his society. Catherine challenged corruption and weakness when people were used to accepting these things. Ignatius challenged old ways of thinking and old ways of doing things when people wanted to keep things as they had always been. Teresa challenged comfort and selfishness when modern Catholics had become very focused on their own well-being. The cost of these challenges was always high. Francis was rejected by his own father and faced suspicion from Church leaders. Catherine was often exhausted and criticized for speaking out of turn as a woman. Ignatius faced accusations that he was changing the Church too much. Teresa faced resistance from wealthy Catholics and from some within the Church who thought she was too demanding. Yet each of these saints knew that their challenge came from love, not from anger or pride. They were not trying to tear down the Church but to help it become what it should be. This love and this faithfulness gave them courage to continue even when things were difficult.
How the Saints Worked Within the Church Structure
An important thing to notice about these saints is that they did not leave the Church or set up competing groups outside it. Francis asked for approval from the Pope and received it, even though the Pope placed limits on what his followers could do. Catherine stayed loyal to the Pope even when she disagreed with his choices and worked to influence him. Ignatius founded a new religious order that was part of the Church, not separate from it. Teresa always worked as a Catholic and accepted the guidance of Church leaders. This shows something important about how real reform happens within the Church. Saints do not refuse to obey; instead, they try to persuade and inspire. They show through their own lives what they believe to be true. They speak and write and work to help others see what they see. They accept the consequences of their choices without becoming bitter or angry. They remain committed to the Church even when the Church resists what they are trying to do. This approach is much harder than simply leaving and starting something new. It requires patience and faith and the willingness to work slowly over a long time. Yet it also means that the change they work for becomes part of the Church itself, not just a separate movement.
The Role of Prayer and Spiritual Insight
Each of these saints based their challenge to the Church on spiritual experience, not just on criticism or complaining. Francis had visions and experiences of God that showed him the meaning of poverty. Catherine experienced mystical prayer that gave her confidence to speak to important leaders. Ignatius developed spiritual practices that helped him understand God’s will more clearly. Teresa had deep experiences of God’s presence that motivated her to serve the poorest. This spiritual foundation made their challenges different from the complaints of ordinary people who were also unhappy with the Church. When someone speaks based only on their own opinions or feelings, people can dismiss them easily. But when someone speaks based on genuine spiritual experience and can show the fruits of their faith in their lives, people have to listen more carefully. The saints understood that real change in the Church had to come from changed hearts, not just from changed rules or policies. They knew that people needed to see new possibilities and new ways of living the faith. They knew that reason alone would not convince people; they also needed to be inspired by example. This is why the lives of the saints matter as much as their words. People could see that Francis really was happier living in poverty than he had been living in wealth. People could see that Catherine’s letters came from genuine concern for the Church, not from pride. People could see that Ignatius truly believed in what he was teaching. This combination of spiritual experience, personal example, and clear words made these saints effective in challenging the Church.
How Church Leaders Responded to Challenge
The Pope and other Church leaders faced difficult choices when saints challenged how things were being done. If they resisted the saints, they looked like they did not want truth or reform. If they accepted what the saints were saying, they had to admit that things were wrong and that changes needed to happen. Some Church leaders became angry or defensive when saints pointed out problems. They used their authority to try to silence the saints or to restrict what they could do. This happened in various ways with each of the saints mentioned. Yet other Church leaders recognized that the saints were right and that listening to them was important. They worked with the saints to find ways to change that would improve the Church. They were willing to admit mistakes and to try new approaches. Over time, most of the changes that the saints fought for became accepted as normal and even necessary. The Church came to see that Francis was right about the importance of serving the poor. The Church recognized the reforms that Catherine had called for. The education system that Ignatius created became a model for Catholic schools around the world. The work of caring for the poorest people that Teresa did became something the whole Church supported. This shows that the saints’ challenges were not really against the Church but for the Church. They wanted the Church to be what it was supposed to be. The leadership of the Church, at least eventually, came to see that these saints were right.
The Relationship Between Tradition and Change
One important truth that the saints understood is that change and tradition are not opposites. Real change means returning to the true tradition, not abandoning it. Francis did not invent something new; he returned to the example that Jesus had given. Catherine did not create a new faith; she called the Church back to what it had always believed. Ignatius did not reject old wisdom; he applied it in new ways to face new problems. Teresa did not reject Catholic teaching; she lived it more completely than most people around her. The saints understood that the Catholic faith has deep roots and that this foundation matters. At the same time, they understood that the faith had to come alive in the present time and speak to the real problems people faced. This is the balance that the Church always has to maintain. It cannot simply keep doing things the way they have always been done because times change and new problems arise. But it also cannot throw away its tradition and act as if everything in the past was wrong. The saints showed how to think about this problem in a wise way. They took the deepest truths of the faith and applied them to their own times. They showed courage in challenging what needed to be challenged. They showed respect for the Church by staying within it and working for change from inside. They show modern Catholics how to love the Church and also to think critically about how the Church could do better.
Saints as Models for Modern Challenges
Modern Catholics might ask what these saints from the past have to teach us now. One lesson is that it is acceptable to see problems in how the Church operates without losing faith in the Church itself. The saints did not pretend that everything was perfect. They looked honestly at what was wrong. At the same time, they worked to fix these problems instead of just walking away. Another lesson is that personal spiritual experience matters and should guide our actions. The saints did not challenge the Church because they wanted attention or because they were proud. They did their work because they felt called by God to do so. A third lesson is that change takes time and requires patience. None of these saints saw all of their hopes fulfilled during their own lifetimes. Francis had to accept that the Pope placed restrictions on his order. Catherine died while still working for reform and seeing results. Ignatius had to watch the Church and the world change in ways he did not fully understand. Teresa died before seeing all of the changes in the Church that she had hoped for. Yet each of them remained faithful and continued their work. They did not become discouraged or angry when change did not happen as fast as they wanted. A fourth lesson is that speaking truth with love is more effective than speaking from anger or pride. The saints corrected problems in the Church, but they did so in ways that showed they cared about the Church. This is an example for any Catholic who wants to see the Church change for the better.
The Cost and the Reward
It is important to note that speaking against popular Catholic practice was not safe or easy for these saints. Francis faced rejection from his own family and from Church leaders. Catherine lived in times of political turmoil and died young, possibly from stress and the physical toll of her work. Ignatius faced suspicion and criticism throughout his life. Teresa was not always understood or supported by other members of her own community. Each of them paid a price for their faithfulness. The Catechism of the Catholic Church teaches that all followers of Christ are called to holiness and that this calling often requires sacrifice (CCC 2013). The saints understood this teaching and lived it out. They did not seek to become famous or to gain power or wealth from their efforts. In fact, choosing to challenge the Church made them less popular with powerful people. Yet the saints found their reward not in worldly success but in knowing that they were doing what God wanted. They trusted that God saw their hearts and knew their intentions. They believed that serving God was worth any cost. This faith gave them strength to continue even when people criticized them or tried to stop them. Modern Catholics can learn from this example that faithfulness to God is more important than being liked or being comfortable. The saints show us that it is possible to love the Church deeply while also seeing its faults and working to change them.
How Saints Challenge Us Today
When we learn about saints who challenged the popular Catholicism of their day, we are being challenged in our own time as well. We must ask ourselves whether we are living our faith in ways that are truly faithful to what Jesus taught. We must ask whether we are making our decisions based on what we believe to be true or based on what is comfortable or easy. We must ask whether we are willing to speak truth even when doing so is difficult. The saints show us that the Catholic faith is not something dead from the past but something living that calls us to change and to grow. They show us that the Church is not perfect and that it needs people who will work to improve it. They show us that we can love the Church and the Pope while also thinking critically about decisions and practices. They show us that real faithfulness to Christ sometimes means being willing to go against the crowd. At the same time, the saints teach us to do this work with humility and with genuine love for the Church. They teach us to stay within the Church structure and to respect its authority while also speaking our truth. They teach us to base our actions on prayer and spiritual insight, not just on our own opinions. They teach us to accept that change takes time and to remain faithful even when we do not see quick results. These are lessons that every Catholic can benefit from learning and thinking about carefully.
Living Out the Prophetic Role in Modern Times
Catholics are called to be prophets in their own times, which means speaking truth to the world and to the Church. This does not mean that every Catholic is called to be as dramatic or as public as the saints we have discussed. But it does mean that every Catholic has a responsibility to think about what the faith really teaches and whether our lives and our choices match that teaching. It means being willing to speak up when we see something wrong, even if it is unpopular. It means doing this in ways that show love and respect, not anger or pride. It means understanding that we might be wrong about some things and being willing to listen to others. It means accepting that change happens slowly and being patient with the Church and with other people. The saints who challenged popular Catholicism show us that this kind of faithful speaking is part of what it means to be a good Catholic. They did not wait for someone else to fix the problems they saw. They did not assume that the leaders of the Church would never listen to them. They spoke their truth and continued to speak it even when they faced resistance. Their example gives modern Catholics permission and encouragement to do the same. At the same time, their example reminds us to do this work with humility and with the understanding that we might not see the full results in our own lifetimes. This balance between courage and humility, between speaking truth and respecting authority, is what the saints teach us through their lives and their work.
Conclusion: The Ongoing Work of Reform
The Church has always had saints who challenged its practices and helped it to grow and change. These saints were not rebels or enemies of the Church; they were lovers of the Church who wanted it to be true to itself. They saw that the faith as it was being lived did not match what the faith really taught. They dedicated themselves to closing that gap. Through their work, the Church changed and improved in many ways. Their examples continue to teach us and to inspire us. When we read about these saints, we are not just learning history. We are learning lessons about how to be faithful to God in our own times. We are learning that it is possible to love the Church and also to see its faults. We are learning that one person can make a difference, even without power or authority. We are learning that speaking truth with love is powerful and can create real change. We are learning that faithfulness to God sometimes requires courage and the willingness to go against the crowd. These lessons are as important today as they were in the times of Francis, Catherine, Ignatius, and Teresa. The Catholic faith continues to call people to holiness and to prophetic witness. The saints show us what this looks like when it is done with genuine love for God and for the Church.
Signup for our Exclusive Newsletter
-
- Join us on Patreon for premium content
- Checkout these Catholic audiobooks
- Get FREE Rosary Book
- Follow us on Flipboard
Discover hidden wisdom in Catholic books; invaluable guides enriching faith and satisfying curiosity. Explore now! #CommissionsEarned
- The Early Church Was the Catholic Church
- The Case for Catholicism - Answers to Classic and Contemporary Protestant Objections
- Meeting the Protestant Challenge: How to Answer 50 Biblical Objections to Catholic Beliefs
As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases. Thank you.